Skip to content 
A personal injury claim in Chicago follows a structured process: you seek medical treatment while documenting injuries, your attorney investigates and gathers evidence, you reach maximum medical improvement, your attorney submits a demand package to the insurer, both sides negotiate settlement, and if negotiations fail, your attorney files suit in Cook County Circuit Court.
Understanding what happens at each stage, from the day of the accident through final settlement or verdict, helps you set realistic expectations, avoid costly mistakes, and choose an attorney who keeps your case moving toward fair recovery.
Walner Law guides clients through every stage of car accident, truck crash, slip-and-fall, and serious injury claims across Chicago and Cook County with clear communication, thorough preparation, and aggressive advocacy when insurers refuse fair compensation.
Key Takeaways for Chicago Personal Injury Claims
- Personal injury claims follow a predictable process: medical treatment, evidence gathering, reaching maximum medical improvement (MMI), demand submission, negotiation, and litigation if necessary
- You’re not required to give recorded statements to the at-fault party’s insurer, and doing so without attorney guidance can harm your claim
- Compensation includes economic damages (medical bills, lost wages, property damage) and non-economic damages (pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life)
- Medical liens from health insurers, Medicare, or hospitals must be repaid from your settlement, reducing your net recovery
- Most cases settle before trial, but filing suit could strengthen settlement negotiations by subjecting defendants to discovery and trial risk
What Are the Steps in a Chicago Personal Injury Claim?
Personal injury claims move through distinct stages, each with specific tasks, deadlines, and strategic decisions.
Immediate Actions After the Accident
The claim process begins at the accident scene, though your priority is safety and medical care, not evidence gathering. Seek medical treatment right away. Go to the emergency room, urgent care, or your primary care doctor. Follow your doctor’s orders, attend all appointments, and keep records of every visit, prescription, and therapy session.
If you’re able, photograph injuries, vehicle damage, hazards that caused your fall, and the surrounding area. Try to obtain witness contact information while memories are fresh and exchange insurance information with all parties involved, including policy numbers and carrier names.
Don’t worry if shock, injuries, or confusion prevented you from gathering evidence at the scene. Walner Law investigates accidents by requesting police reports from the Chicago Police Department or the Illinois State Police, obtaining surveillance footage from businesses or traffic cameras, tracking down witnesses, and reconstructing the events through expert analysis, if necessary.
Hiring an Attorney and Investigation
Contact a Chicago personal injury attorney early. Walner Law offers free consultations where we review your accident details, medical records, and insurance information to evaluate your case.
If we take your case, we immediately begin investigating by requesting police reports, obtaining surveillance footage before it’s deleted, sending spoliation letters to preserve evidence like truck black-box data, and interviewing witnesses.
We handle communication with insurers. You’re not required to give recorded statements to the at-fault party’s insurance company, and we advise clients not to do so without attorney guidance. Adjusters cab use recorded statements to lock you into descriptions they’ll later use to deny or reduce your claim.
Medical Treatment and Reaching Maximum Medical Improvement
Continue treatment until you reach maximum medical improvement (MMI). Your treating physician determines MMI, not the insurance adjuster. Settling before MMI means you waive the right to claim future medical expenses, additional surgeries, or worsening symptoms.
MMI timing varies by injury type. Soft-tissue injuries might stabilize with physical therapy and chiropractic care. Broken bones require healing time, follow-up imaging, and assessment of permanent limitations. Herniated discs might respond to conservative treatment or require steroid injections and eventual surgery. Traumatic brain injuries need neurological evaluations over extended periods.
Walner Law coordinates with your medical providers to track treatment progress, obtain updated records showing improvement or plateauing symptoms, and ensure we don’t demand settlement prematurely.
Demand Package Submission
Once you reach MMI, Walner Law prepares a comprehensive demand package including medical records from providers, itemized billing statements, wage-loss documentation from your employer, photos of injuries and accident scenes, police or incident reports, and a detailed demand letter.
The demand letter calculates your total damages, economic and non-economic, and justifies your compensation request with evidence, medical opinions, and legal arguments.
We submit the demand to the at-fault party’s insurance carrier, triggering their review process. Adjusters evaluate the demand, request additional documentation, and make initial settlement offers.
Settlement Negotiations
Initial offers are almost always low. Adjusters hope you’ll accept quick money without understanding your case’s value. They lowball pain and suffering damages, challenge medical necessity, and argue that treatment was excessive or unrelated to the accident.
Walner Law responds with counter-demands backed by evidence, jury verdict data, and medical opinions that link every treatment to the accident. Negotiation rounds continue until both sides agree or talks break down.
Some cases settle after one or two rounds; others require extensive back-and-forth as the insurer gradually increases its offers, and we evaluate whether the settlements meet your needs.
Filing Suit in Cook County Circuit Court
If the insurer refuses to negotiate reasonably, Walner Law files suit in Cook County Circuit Court. Filing suit doesn’t mean you’ve committed to trial, but it escalates negotiations by subjecting the defendant to discovery, court deadlines, and trial risk.
Discovery involves written interrogatories, document production, depositions of parties and witnesses, and retention of expert witnesses. As evidence mounts during discovery, settlement postures often shift. Insurers who initially denied liability might settle after depositions reveal their policyholder lied about fault.
Cases also settle at court-ordered mediation or shortly before trial as both sides face the costs and uncertainty of proceeding to a verdict.
Do I Have to Talk to the Insurance Adjuster?
You must report the accident to your own insurance carrier promptly. Your policy requires it, and failing to notify your insurer can jeopardize coverage for collision repairs, MedPay benefits, or uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) claims.
You’re not required to give recorded statements to the at-fault party’s insurance adjuster. The at-fault driver’s insurer will call asking for your version of events, requesting medical releases, and pressuring you to settle quickly. Adjusters use these conversations to lock you into statements they’ll later use against you.
Politely decline recorded statements and refer the adjuster to your attorney. Once you hire Walner Law, we handle communication with the at-fault party’s insurer. We provide the information they’re legally entitled to receive and push back on unreasonable requests designed to delay or deny your claim.
What Compensation Can I Expect in Illinois?
Illinois law divides personal injury damages into economic and non-economic categories.
Economic Damages
Economic damages reimburse you for measurable financial losses:
Medical expenses:
- Emergency-room treatment and ambulance transport
- Hospitalization, surgery, and follow-up visits with specialists
- Physical therapy, prescription medications, and medical equipment
- Future treatment costs if your doctor recommends ongoing care
Lost income:
- Wages missed during recovery (hourly or salaried)
- Lost future income if permanent disability reduces earning capacity
- Self-employment income proven through tax returns and client invoices
- Bonuses and commissions you would have earned
Property damage:
- Vehicle repair costs or fair-market value if totaled
- Rental-car expenses during repairs or until total-loss settlement
- Towing and storage costs from the accident scene
- Diminished value (vehicle’s reduced resale value after accident history)
You prove economic damages with itemized statements, pay stubs, tax returns, and receipts. Illinois courts require documentation for every claimed expense.
Non-Economic Damages
Non-economic damages compensate you for intangible losses:
- Physical pain, emotional distress, and mental anguish
- Fear, anxiety, and loss of enjoyment of life
- Inability to participate in hobbies, activities, and family events
- Disfigurement, scarring, and permanent disability
- Loss of companionship (claimed by spouses in loss-of-consortium claims)
Attorneys and adjusters calculate non-economic damages using the multiplier method (medical expenses × 1.5 to 5 based on injury severity) or per-diem method (daily rate × recovery days). However, there is no official formula used by juries.
Illinois doesn’t cap compensatory damages in most personal injury cases. You may recover the full amount a jury awards for medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering.
What Is Maximum Medical Improvement and Why Does It Matter?
Maximum medical improvement (MMI) is the point where your condition has stabilized and further significant recovery is unlikely. Your treating physician determines MMI based on your response to treatment, imaging results, and ongoing symptoms.
MMI matters because settling before you reach it means you waive the right to claim future medical expenses or worsening symptoms. If you settle after physical therapy but later need surgery, the insurer won’t reopen your claim. If you accept a settlement before discovering you have permanent limitations that prevent you from returning to work, you can’t go back for additional compensation.
Walner Law doesn’t rush clients into premature settlements. We coordinate with medical providers to track treatment progress and ensure you’ve reached MMI before submitting demand packages. This protects your recovery and helps us claim past, present, and reasonably anticipated future expenses.
Will I Have to Go to Court in Cook County?
Most personal injury cases settle before trial, and data suggests fewer than 5% of filed cases actually reach a jury verdict. Filing a lawsuit in Cook County Circuit Court doesn’t mean you’ll go to trial; it means you’ve preserved your rights under Illinois’s statute of limitations and escalated negotiations.
Settlement discussions continue throughout litigation. Many cases resolve during discovery, at court-ordered mediation, or shortly before trial as evidence mounts and both sides face the costs and uncertainty of proceeding to verdict.
Cases go to court when liability is disputed, insurers make unreasonably low offers that ignore serious injuries, damages significantly exceed policy limits, or parties disagree fundamentally on case value. Walner Law prepares every case for trial from day one, which strengthens our negotiating position and ensures we’re ready if the case doesn’t settle.
How Do Medical Liens and Health Insurance Reimbursements Work?
Your settlement check doesn’t equal your gross recovery. Medical providers, health insurers, Medicare, Medicaid, and your attorney all take cuts before you receive your net recovery.
Types of Liens
Health insurance subrogation liens: If your health insurer paid your medical bills, they may assert a subrogation lien requiring repayment from your settlement. The lien amount equals what they paid for accident-related treatment.
Medicare and Medicaid liens: These are federal obligations that must be satisfied before you receive settlement funds. Medicare and Medicaid track payments for accident-related treatment and file liens to recover those amounts.
Hospital liens: Illinois law under 770 ILCS 23 allows hospitals to file liens in Cook County Circuit Court for unpaid emergency and hospital services. These liens must be satisfied or contested before settlement.
Attorney liens: Your contingency fee agreement gives your attorney a lien on the recovery. The attorney’s fee and case costs are deducted before other liens are paid.
Lien Negotiation
Liens are negotiable. Walner Law sends lien-reduction letters citing case weaknesses, comparative fault, and the risk that the lienholder would recover nothing if the case went to trial and you lost. Many health insurers accept a reduced lien amount. However, Medicare liens are harder to negotiate but are still subject to federal reduction formulas.
We review all liens before you sign a release to avoid post-settlement surprises. Understanding your net recovery after all deductions helps you make informed decisions about settlement versus trial.
FAQ for Chicago Personal Injury Claims
Claim timing depends on medical recovery, liability clarity, insurance evaluation, and negotiation progress. Straightforward cases with clear liability and completed treatment may settle relatively quickly once you reach maximum medical improvement. Complex cases with disputed fault, ongoing medical care, or bad-faith insurer tactics take longer and may require filing suit in Cook County Circuit Court.
Adjusters review your demand package, request additional documentation, and make initial settlement offers. If the initial offer is low, Walner Law responds with counteroffers backed by evidence and negotiates until we reach a fair compensation or determine that the insurer won’t settle reasonably, at which point we file suit.
You can handle minor claims yourself if injuries are minimal, liability is clear, and the insurer makes a fair offer that covers all your damages. However, even “minor” injuries sometimes have long-term complications, and adjusters might exploit unrepresented claimants. Walner Law offers free consultations to evaluate whether your claim justifies attorney representation.
An insurance claim is an informal request for compensation filed with the at-fault party’s insurer. Most claims settle without filing suit. A lawsuit is a formal legal action filed in Cook County Circuit Court when insurance negotiations fail. Filing suit doesn’t mean you’ll go to trial, but it subjects the defendant to discovery, court deadlines, and trial risk.
Walner Law prioritizes client communication. We prioritize swift responses and provide updates about settlement negotiations, medical lien developments, and litigation progress. You have direct access to the attorneys handling your case, and we explain what’s happening and what to expect next.
Clear Guidance Through Every Stage of Your Claim
Personal injury claims involve multiple stages, complex negotiations, and strategic decisions that affect your recovery. Walner Law guides clients through car accidents, truck crashes, slip-and-fall claims, and serious injuries across Chicago and Cook County with clear communication, thorough preparation, and aggressive advocacy.
We handle the investigation, gather evidence, coordinate with medical providers, negotiate with adjusters, and file suit when insurers refuse fair compensation. You focus on recovery while we manage the legal process, keeping you informed and answering questions at every stage.
Call (312) 410-8496 today for a free consultation.
