What Questions Should I Ask My Chicago Car Accident Attorney?

Picture of Walner Law®
Walner Law®

July 5, 2025

Question Mark and Judge's Gavel
Share

After a car accident, finding the right legal help can feel daunting. Many people aren’t sure where to begin. Asking the right questions can help you feel confident in your decision.

If you are searching for a Chicago car accident attorney, here are the key questions you should discuss during your consultation.

Get Your Free Consultation

What Is Your Experience with Cases Like Mine?

Not every accident is the same. Your attorney’s past work can provide insight into how they will handle your case. Ask them about similar cases they’ve worked on. This can tell you how comfortable they are with situations like yours.

Consider these clarifying questions:

  • Have they handled cases involving serious injuries or property damage before?
  • Do they regularly deal with insurance companies who might try to downplay or deny claims?
  • What were the outcomes of their previous cases that align with yours?

Understanding these factors can give you a better sense of their familiarity with the challenges specific to your situation.

What Steps Will You Take to Investigate My Case?

A lawyer is investigating car accident with toy cars

Knowing what will happen during the legal process can ease some of your uncertainty. Your attorney should explain how they will gather evidence, build your claim, and negotiate on your behalf.

Each of these steps will contribute to building a strong foundation for your case.

Key parts of an investigation could include:

  1. Obtaining police reports and accident scene photos.
  2. Speaking with witnesses to the event.
  3. Reviewing medical records and other documentation.

A clear explanation of their process will help you understand how your attorney plans to protect your interests.

How Do You Communicate with Clients?

Good communication is vital during your case. You’ll want an attorney who keeps you informed. Ask about their approach to client communication. For instance, do they provide regular updates, or do clients need to reach out first?

Here are three points to discuss:

  1. How often can you expect updates about your case?
  2. Will you communicate directly with the attorney or work through their team?
  3. What methods do they use to stay in touch (email, phone, in-person meetings)?

Clear communication ensures you’re never left guessing about your case’s status.

What Are the Possible Outcomes of My Case?

While no attorney can guarantee results, they should be able to provide an honest evaluation of the possible outcomes. Understanding what might happen will help you set realistic expectations. Discuss the potential paths your case may take.

Ask these questions:

  • Is a settlement likely, or is court a possibility?
  • What kind of compensation can you seek for medical bills, lost wages, or other expenses?
  • How long might the process take?

These answers will give you a better idea of what to prepare for as your case progresses.

What Are Your Fees, and How Are They Structured?

What is a contingency fee

This is the big question, right? Legal costs are important to discuss upfront. Many personal injury attorneys work on a contingency basis, meaning they only get paid if you win your case. 

Clarify this during your consultation to avoid surprises later. Here’s a simple breakdown of questions to ask:

  • How much is the contingency fee, and are there any additional costs?
  • Are there upfront fees if the case doesn’t settle out of court?
  • Will you get a clear payment breakdown before signing any agreements?

Transparency in financial matters helps you make an informed decision.

Do Our Schedules Coincide?

Life doesn’t stop after an accident. If you’re dealing with injuries, work responsibilities, or a busy family schedule, flexibility matters. A good attorney should be willing to meet or adjust to your needs.

Talk about:

  • Whether consultations can be done by phone or virtually.
  • Their availability for meetings, especially if your schedule is tight.
  • Support options like providing transportation for client meetings, if necessary.

This can give you a clearer sense of how accessible and accommodating they will be throughout the case.

Why Should I Trust You with My Case?

This question helps you gauge their confidence and sincerity. An attorney should address your concerns thoughtfully and explain why they believe they are the right fit for your case.

Review their responses to see if their values and approach align with what you need. Think about their responses to these areas:

  • Their long-term commitment to clients in Chicago.
  • Their dedication to fair results and client satisfaction.
  • Any additional resources they offer beyond legal representation.

Getting a perspective on their dedication and support can help you feel reassured in choosing them.

How Can I Protect My Privacy During the Case?

After a car accident, sharing personal details can feel uncomfortable. When you start a legal case, your information might be shared with various parties, including insurance companies and medical providers. Protecting your privacy is important, and your attorney can guide you on safeguarding your personal details while building a strong case.

Attorneys work to keep sensitive information confidential, but there are steps you can take to help protect yourself as well. By being cautious and proactive, you can limit unnecessary exposure of your personal details during the legal process.

Here are some actionable tips for protecting your privacy during a car accident case:

  • Limit What You Share Publicly: Avoid posting about the accident or your injuries on social media. Posts can be used against you by opposing parties.
  • Only Talk About Your Case With Your Attorney: Be cautious about discussing your case with friends, family, or coworkers. What you share might unintentionally reach others.
  • Review Documents Before Signing: Ensure you understand how your information will be used, especially when signing medical release forms.
  • Secure Your Communications: If you are emailing or texting about your case, use a secure device and avoid public Wi-Fi when possible.
  • Request Copies of Shared Documents: Ask for evidence of what documents and information your attorney shares with others during your case.

Protect your privacy by staying informed and cautious every step of the way.

What Should I Do If the Other Driver’s Insurance Contacts Me?

After a car accident, it’s common for the other driver’s insurance company to reach out to you. This can feel intimidating, especially if you’re unsure how to respond.

They minimize payouts and try to gather information to use against your case. Knowing how to handle these calls helps protect your rights.

When contacted, staying calm and avoiding giving detailed information about the accident is crucial. Speaking with your attorney first ensures that you don’t say anything that could weaken your claim. An attorney can deal directly with the insurance company, so you don’t have to worry about making a mistake.

Here are some key steps to follow if the other driver’s insurance company contacts you:

  • Do Not Admit Fault: Avoid saying anything that could be interpreted as taking the blame for the accident. Even a simple apology could be used against you later.
  • Limit What You Share: Stick to basic details like your name, the date of the accident, and the car involved. There’s no need to provide lengthy explanations.
  • Refuse Recorded Statements: Politely decline if they ask to record your statement. You are not legally obligated to agree to this.
  • Write Down Everything: Keep a record of the date, time, and content of the conversation, including who you spoke with.
  • Refer Them to Your Attorney: Clearly state that your lawyer will handle all communications moving forward. This protects you from being pressured into saying something you shouldn’t.

These steps can help you avoid common pitfalls and protect your case from being undermined. If you have any doubts or feel uneasy when speaking with the other driver’s insurance, your attorney can take over and provide the support you need.

Can I Still Pursue a Case If I Was Partially at Fault?

One common misconception after a car accident is that being partially at fault means you lose the right to seek compensation. This is not true. Illinois uses a law called “comparative negligence” to determine how fault is handled in accident cases.

Under this law, you can still pursue damages for your injuries as long as you were less than 51% at fault for the accident. Here’s how it typically works. Each party involved is assigned a percentage of fault based on their actions. This percentage directly affects how much compensation you can receive.

For example, if you were 20% at fault and awarded $50,000 in damages, your final amount would be reduced by 20%, leaving you with $40,000. The goal of comparative negligence is to ensure fairness and account for everyone’s actions.

If you were partially at fault, consider these key points to better understand your options:

  1. Fault Is Not Always Clear-Cut: Determining fault often involves reviewing evidence like police reports, witness statements, and traffic laws. Your attorney can help show how other factors contributed to the accident.
  2. Minor Fault May Not Hurt Your Case: Small mistakes, such as not using a turn signal, don’t mean you’re ineligible for compensation. The focus is on the overall picture of responsibility.
  3. Communicate With Your Attorney: Be honest about the details of the accident. Your lawyer can address any concerns and ensure the fault assigned to you is fair.
  4. Medical Bills and Other Costs Are Still Considered: Even if you share partial fault, you shouldn’t have to bear the full financial burden from someone else’s negligence.

Discussing your case with an attorney ensures you know your options and gives you the confidence to move forward, even if fault isn’t completely on the other party.

What Happens If the At-Fault Driver Doesn’t Have Insurance?

Concept of Uninsured Motorist Coverage write on sticky notes isolated on Wooden Table.

Finding out the at-fault driver doesn’t have insurance can be frustrating. However, it doesn’t mean you’re out of options. This is where uninsured motorist (UM) coverage comes into play.

Illinois requires all drivers to carry UM coverage as part of their auto insurance policy. This means your own insurance can step in to cover costs like medical bills, lost wages, and damages when the at-fault driver lacks insurance. Understanding how this process works can help reduce your stress during an already challenging time.

When you file a claim with your uninsured motorist coverage, your insurance company essentially takes on the role of the at-fault driver’s insurer. While this may sound straightforward, it’s still important to work with an attorney to protect your rights and receive a fair settlement.

Every accident is different, and having legal support can make answering questions or negotiating with your insurance provider a lot smoother. Here are some steps you should take if the at-fault driver doesn’t have insurance:

  • Notify Your Insurance Company Immediately: Contact your insurer as soon as possible to report the accident and initiate a UM claim. They will guide you through the process but may ask for detailed information about the accident.
  • Document the Scene and Gather Evidence: Take photos of the accident, note any witness information, and keep records of your medical visits and repair costs. These details can strengthen your case.
  • Review Your Policy Coverage Limits: Illinois mandates a minimum UM coverage, but many people purchase higher limits. Check your policy to understand how much compensation you may be eligible to receive.
  • Work With Your Attorney: Although UM claims are made through your insurance, disputes over payments can still arise. A car accident attorney can help ensure that the claim is handled fairly and that you receive the compensation you need.

Facing a situation where the at-fault driver doesn’t have insurance can feel overwhelming, but you’re not alone. Taking the right steps and understanding your coverage helps protect you financially.

Schedule Your Consultation Today

Choosing the right attorney often begins with asking the right questions. If you’ve been injured in an accident and need a knowledgeable Chicago car accident attorney, Walner Law is here to help. Call (312) 410-8496 to schedule a consultation and reclaim your peace of mind.

Get Your Free Consultation

Related Posts

July 21st

Fatal Motorcycle–Dump Truck Crash Shuts Down Illinois Route 53 Near Rand Road

Arlington Heights, IL — A deadly collision between a motorcycle and a dump truck early Monday morning forced Illinois Route 53 to close in both directions for…
July 18th

Five‑Vehicle Pileup Closes Northbound I‑94 Near Dundee Road; One Fatality

Northbrook, IL — A five‑vehicle collision on northbound Interstate 94 north of Dundee Road forced a complete shutdown of the highway Wednesday morning and…
July 14th

What Do I Do After a Hit and Run Accident in Chicago?

A car hits you, and the driver speeds away. You’re left injured, confused, and unsure of what to do. A hit and run accident…
Get your Free Consultation
Take the first step towards justice and solidify your future.